Home » all | organic acids

Organix Step 1: Mitochondrial Function

19. April 2010 by Eve Bralley, PhD, CCN 7 Comments

Mitochondria are the powerhouses of cells. They generate energy from the fats, carbohydrates, and proteins that we eat. The Organix test evaluates how well our mitochondria make energy from foods. When your patient presents with fatigue, weight loss resistance, overweight, or metabolic syndrome, this information can be very useful in designing an effective therapy.

Fats

The most efficient way to make energy (ATP) from fatty acids is by B-oxidation in the mitochondria. Carnitine and B2 are needed to shuttle these fatty acids across the mitochondrial membrane. If your patient is deficient in either of these nutrients, the fats can’t cross into the mitochondria and are metabolized in a less efficient manner in peroxisomes. The end products of this reaction are adipate, suberate, and ethylmalonate. So, when these compounds are high in the urine, it tells us that fats are not getting into the mitochondria, thus leading to a decrease in energy production and trouble with “burning” fats. Carnitine receives a lot of press in popular media as being a weight-loss supplement for this reason. Once carnitine levels are restored, fats are “burned” and people can lose weight and enjoy improved energy levels.

Effects of Carnitine Insufficiency

Carbohydrates

Many of you may remember memorizing the steps of glycolysis back in college biochemistry. Glycolysis is the pathyway that takes sugar (glucose) and converts it to pyruvate so that it can enter the citric acid cycle and finally produce ATP in the electron transport chain—a process called cellular respiration. Each molecule of glucose, by the end of cellular respiration, can yield up to 36 ATP.

High levels of pyruvate in the urine can indicate a functional block in this cellular respiration process. To enter the citric acid cycle, pyruvate needs to be metabolized by a large enzyme complex, pyruvate dehydrogenase, a process that requires vitamins B1, B2, B3, B5, and lipoic acid. High levels of pyruvate in the urine can imply deficiencies of one or more of these vitamins.

Under anaerobic conditions, lactate, not pyruvate, is the primary end product of glycolysis. When lactate is high, metabolic acidosis can ensue due to hypoxia, metabolic syndrome, alcohol intake, and many pharmaceutical drugs. Addressing the underlying causes as mentioned above as well as supporting with nutrients such as coenzyme Q10, lipoic acid, and thiamine (B1) is helpful to lower lactate in urine.

The ketone body B-hydroxybutyrate is made from fatty acids when there isn’t enough sugar to use for energy. The term “ketone body” became popular with the introduction of the Atkins diet, which is low in carbohydrates and high in protein and fat. The body prefers to burn carbohydrates as its first source fuel, but when they are exhausted the body uses fat. Ketones are a by-product of this process. Your patient may show high b-hydroxybutyrate if he is on a low-carbohydrate diet, or if he has been fasting for longer than 12 hours. If neither is the case, then you have a great marker for monitoring insulin resistance, and metabolic syndrome. If sugars cannot get into the cell to be used for energy, the body begins making ketones from fatty acids. Interventions include improving insulin sensitivity by a low-glycemic-index diet, exercise, fish oil, and chromium.

Citric Acid Cycle (CAC)

Dietary fat, carbohydrates, and protein are metabolized to a common metabolic intermediate, acetyl-CoA. Acetyl CoA flows directly into the citric acid cycle. Proper functioning of this cycle generates enough NADH to help create ATP in the final stage of energy production, the electron transport chain (ETC). Abnormal spilling of CAC intermediates in the urine can indicate mitochondrial inefficiencies in energy production. Many cofactors are involved in the conversions of these intermediates, including the minerals iron, magnesium, manganese, and the B-vitamins. The ETC is heavily dependent on CoQ10 for its function. If there is a deficiency in CoQ10, CAC intermediates can elevate in the urine. Severity of the CoQ10 deficiency can be correlated with the amount and number of CAC intermediates found in the urine. This information becomes useful when determining whether or not your patient needs only 30 mg of CoQ10, or 300 mg.

CoQ10 Severe Deficiency

If CoQ10 status is normal, extreme high levels like those shown above can be a sign of a greater problem such as heavy metals attacking the ETC. An elevated level of 8-OH-d-guanosine (to be discussed in further detail in a future blog) is a supporting marker for such a hypothesis.

Low urinary concentrations of the CAC intermediates can be a sign of amino acid deficiency, as amino acids are a main filling agent to the cycle. When the CAC intermediates are low, consider supplementation with a free-form amino acid powder to improve energy production. Even better, consider a more targeted approach by testing your patient for fasting plasma amino acid levels to determine a customized compounded blend of free-form amino acids.

In conclusion, urinary organic acid analysis is a great way to get a snapshot of your patient’s mitochondrial function as it relates to energy production and utilization of the foods they eat. Correcting imbalances can make huge differences in your patient’s energy level and ability to lose weight.

Next week we'll take a look at Step 2: B-Vitamin Status. Feel free to comment below as always!

Additional Resources:

Comments (7) -

Nathan Goodyear
Nathan Goodyear United States
4/19/2010 12:23:17 PM #

Beautiful summary of the biochemistry.  I have found these tests invaluable in helping many of my clients.

I look forward to reading your upcoming post: "An elevated level of 8-OH-d-guanosine (to be discussed in further detail in a future blog) is a supporting marker for such a hypothesis". I am not aware of that hypothesis

Reply

Eve Bralley
Eve Bralley United States
4/19/2010 2:54:45 PM #

Thank you! I am glad you see the usefulness of these tests. It helps take out so much of the guess work, doesn't it?  

Here's a sneak peak for you...heavy metals can harm  mitochondrial function, and also cause free radical damage to our DNA.  8-OH-dG is a marker of oxidative damage to the DNA.  So when you see elevated levels in both CAC intermediates and 8-OH-dG, you can begin to question exposures to metals.  

Thanks for your feedback!

Reply

Nathan Goodyear
Nathan Goodyear United States
4/30/2010 8:04:20 AM #

Does the heavy metal results present in the ION panel with elevated CAC intermediates and 8-OH-dG equal than a heavy metal challenge?  Or, is it in fact a better evaluation, because it shows a functional effect of heavy metal exposure?

Reply

Nathalie
Nathalie Australia
5/18/2010 10:54:33 PM #

Thank you for making it so clear!

You wrote: If CoQ10 status is normal, extreme high levels like those shown above can be a sign of a greater problem such as heavy metals attacking the ETC.

You assess the CoQ10 status as normal with a blood test?

Reply

CHIOMA CHIAWA
CHIOMA CHIAWA United States
5/26/2010 9:37:09 PM #

Great article and thanks for expanding on 8-OH-dG.
Chioma

Reply

Richard Lord
Richard Lord United States
8/20/2010 5:23:36 PM #

Dr. Eve has been a bit out of pocket, so I'll try to catch up for her in response to your inputs.

Regarding heavy metal assessment:
In one sense, finding high 8OHdG and CAC intermediates along with elevated toxic heavy metals is the ultimate discovery because you see both the cause and potential effect of the toxic element. The down side is that the CAC abnormalities are presumed effects since other things could potentially be going on in addition to the elevated toxic metal. Of course, if the oxidative stress and CAC markers normalize when the toxic elements are removed, you have a nice confirmation that the two were, indeed, linked causally.

Regarding the marker relationships to CoQ10:
I think that Dr. Bralley was pointing out how we sometimes find highly elevated CAC markers when the patient's serum CoQ10 levels look quite good. That means that whatever is causing the perturbation is having an even more strong effect. So, if the origin is elevated body burdens of toxic elements, then they are creating a level of mitochondrial interference that mimics the effect of CoQ10 deficiency.

Reply

Dr. Jake Wiler
Dr. Jake Wiler
4/2/2012 4:17:37 AM #

This was quitewell said. A good bit has been presented on these concerns lately, nonetheless I prefer this well thought-out perspective.

Reply

Pingbacks and trackbacks (2)+

Add comment




  Country flag
biuquote
  • Comment
  • Preview
Loading